Corner of Berkshire & Fairfax Message Board

General Category => Investment Ideas => Topic started by: Olmsted on January 16, 2014, 10:08:00 AM

Title: MMAB - MuniMae, LLC
Post by: Olmsted on January 16, 2014, 10:08:00 AM
I previously brought this idea up in a different thread, but I think it is time for its own.  I have quoted my original thoughts below, interspersed with some actual sources.

MMAB.  I've been meaning to start a thread on this, but no time.  I'll add some actual numbers to this when I start the thread.  For now, a teaser.

The asset base is very complicated and the balance sheet needs numerous adjustments to arrive at  a real net asset value.  I believe this results in a lot of hidden value.  Further, management is incentivized to start realizing this hidden value, having been very aggressively buying shares over the last year, sometimes at prices as high as $1.30(ish). 

An incomplete list of the hidden value:

-Fair value of the muni bond portfolio (most of the company's assets) is above carrying value on the balance sheet.

Quote
Exhibit A adjusts our balance sheet to remove certain funds and ventures that are consolidated on our GAAP balance sheet... we have not included the incremental fair value associated with those bonds occurring since consolidation
http://seekingalpha.com/article/1853351-municipal-mortgage-and-equitys-ceo-discusses-q3-2013-results-earnings-call-transcript?part=single

How much is that "incremental fair value"? 

Quote
We had bonds with a book carrying value of $288.9 million comprised of multi-family tax exempt bonds and community development district bonds and as provided for in our disclosures we estimated the fair value of these bonds to be $321.4 million at September 30, 2013 which was $32.5 million higher than our book carrying value.
http://seekingalpha.com/article/1853351-municipal-mortgage-and-equitys-ceo-discusses-q3-2013-results-earnings-call-transcript?part=single

-Some of the debt is collateralized only by bonds on the balance sheet.  In essence, these bonds were sold, but didn't qualify for sales treatment.  The bonds that collateralize the debt are carried at less than the face of the debt - which means you can make an upward adjustment to net assets.

When going back through the 10Qs and Ks I cannot find the original numbers I had used.  Below explains some of the accounting issue - but it doesn't give the size of the related asset that is consolidated.  This isn't necessary for the thesis, and if I find it again I will update accordingly.

Quote
Included in the debt balance of $365 million on line 9 was $146.3 million related to the bond portfolio. This includes total return swap borrowings of $51.9 million and secured borrowings of $94.4 million because of bonds that were legally sold but held to receive sale accounting with a total annualized pay rate of about 5% as of September 30, 2013.
http://seekingalpha.com/article/1853351-municipal-mortgage-and-equitys-ceo-discusses-q3-2013-results-earnings-call-transcript?part=single

-There is owned real estate carried at what may be a lowball value.
-Ownership stakes in some solare facilities.
-The company owns a stake in an African housing company, the value of which is not immediately apparent on the balance sheet.

The most recent 10K puts their ownership of International Housing Solutions at 83%.  AUM was $230m as of the 2010 10K.

-Tax credits.  At least $20m, from low-income housing deals

$24m to be precise.  They do not start to expire until 2027.  Also, these are tax credits, not NOLs - so they should reduce any future taxable income on a 1:1 basis.

-NOLs!  A lot.  Like $1bn+
It is difficult to estimate these because of all the consolidated entities, the LLC-corporation conversion, and etc.   The 2010 10K has cumulative NOLs up to that point in time.  They are considerable.  When I asked IR for an update, they were somewhat vague and told me to look in the next 10K.  There is no intention to put the NOLs on the balance sheet at this point.

-I neglected to include ongoing share buybacks:

Quote
As of November 8, 2013 we repurchased 1.1 million common shares in average price of $1.34.
http://seekingalpha.com/article/1853351-municipal-mortgage-and-equitys-ceo-discusses-q3-2013-results-earnings-call-transcript?part=single

Just valuing the cash and bond portfolio (including the non-recourse debt), I get to an asset value net of debt around $2.30.  Everything else is upside.

Since I cannot find the failed-sale accounting/non-recourse debt adjustment at this time, let's just say ~$2 "real-world" equity per share plus a grab bag of goodies (NOLs, tax credits, intl housing, etc.) that are hard to value:

51.6m equity from the 30 Sept balance sheet, which is adjusted for consolidated entities (http://app.quotemedia.com/data/downloadFiling?webmasterId=101533&ref=9232728&type=PDF&symbol=MMAB&companyName=Municipal+Mortgage+%26+Equity+LLC&formType=8-K&dateFiled=2013-11-15)

+32.5m delta between fair value and carrying value of bond portfolio

42.2m shares outstanding

There are still a lot of moving parts, although we should have more transparency into the asset base as this transformation settles out.  What we do not have at the moment is really any visibility into what operations going forward will look like.  On the last conference call, when asked about the company's future plans, the CEO gave us some hints:

Quote
I should start by saying we are very much in the middle of certain strategic planning discussions at the Board level and ultimately the decisions about the future of the company will be made as a result of those conversations. But to sort of give you a sense of out of where opportunity where I think opportunity exist, first if you look back at the history of the company the most of what we have done has been in the multifamily space. And in particular multifamily rental space and we believe that, that is an area where we can mine our past relationships, mine our understanding of markets, our relationships with vendors. And that there will be opportunities for us there
http://seekingalpha.com/article/1853351-municipal-mortgage-and-equitys-ceo-discusses-q3-2013-results-earnings-call-transcript?part=single

This largely comes down to management, their competence, imagination, and networks.  But there are a lot of levers for management to pull, and a lot of value they can potentially generate.  Some risk, lots of opportunity.

By the way, thanks to @ErditCokaj for bringing this one back to my attention and discussing his analysis with me.  Any errors, of course, are my own.
Title: Re: MMAB - MuniMae, LLC
Post by: no_thanks on January 16, 2014, 07:24:45 PM
Nice digging on this one.  Looks really interesting.  What did they transform themselves from to get to where they are now? 
Title: Re: MMAB - MuniMae, LLC
Post by: Olmsted on January 19, 2014, 04:31:54 PM
Nice digging on this one.  Looks really interesting.  What did they transform themselves from to get to where they are now? 

Well according to the last 10K before they imploded:

Quote
We operate through four business segments:

  •   Through our debt segment we (1) invest in tax exempt bonds and bond securitizations; (2) make taxable construction, supplemental and permanent loans; (3) provide loan servicing; and (4) originate loans that are ultimately sold to government sponsored enterprises (“GSEs”), such as the Federal National Mortgage Association (“Fannie Mae”), the Federal Home Loan Mortgage Corporation (“Freddie Mac”) and the Government National Mortgage Association (“Ginnie Mae”) or insured by agencies such as the Federal Housing Administration (“FHA”) and the U.S. Department of Housing and Urban Development (“HUD”). 

  •   Through our tax credit equity segment we provide tax credit equity syndication and asset management services 

  •   Through our structured finance segment we invest in other real estate-related securities, including equity investments in real estate operating partnerships, tax exempt and taxable bonds, bond securitizations and taxable loans. 

  •   Through our fund management segment we (1) provide loan origination, loan servicing, investment advisory, asset management and other related services and (2) invest in real estate operating partnerships. 

Our Debt Segment

Through our debt segment, we engage in a variety of real estate finance activities, including:

  •   Investing in tax exempt bonds and bond securitizations; 

  •   Originating taxable construction, supplemental and permanent loans; and 

  •   Originating, selling and servicing loans that we sell to GSEs. 

Some discerning readers pointed out a few items, which I attempt to address with the following follow-ups and clarifications:

-Some of the debt is collateralized only by bonds on the balance sheet.  In essence, these bonds were sold, but didn't qualify for sales treatment.  The bonds that collateralize the debt are carried at less than the face of the debt - which means you can make an upward adjustment to net assets.

When going back through the 10Qs and Ks I cannot find the original numbers I had used.  Below explains some of the accounting issue - but it doesn't give the size of the related asset that is consolidated.  This isn't necessary for the thesis, and if I find it again I will update accordingly.

This hints at the fact that most of the debt is recourse only to specific collateral, not to the parent.  I double-checked with IR and they confirmed that yes, the vast majority is non-recourse, but that some small proportion of their financing had provisions that could subject the parent to some liability.  It is difficult to put an exact number on these, but it is my understanding that they are essentially insignificant.

I previously brought this idea up in a different thread, but I think it is time for its own.  I have quoted my original thoughts below, interspersed with some actual sources.

-Tax credits.  At least $20m, from low-income housing deals

$24m to be precise.  They do not start to expire until 2027.  Also, these are tax credits, not NOLs - so they should reduce any future taxable income on a 1:1 basis.

Additionally, I was informed that there are ways the company could effectively sell these.  Transcaction costs might eat up around 10% of the value.  I have a somewhat involved paper that explains how this works for green-energy tax credits.  Although it is not a direct analogy, I would imagine the structures are somewhat similar - if there is interest I will post a link.

-There is owned real estate carried at what may be a lowball value.

We got some good news on Friday that highlighted the REO and hinted that it is probably undervalued:

Quote
A New York investment firm has purchased the 200-unit The Meadows apartment complex close to Bartlett for more than $9 million.

An entity affiliated with New York-based RCP General Inc. bought the 100,080-square-foot complex at 2154 Meadow Glade Lane in Memphis, north of Raleigh-Lagrange Road near Sycamore View, from an entity of Baltimore-based MuniMaE, according to public Shelby County deed transaction records.

Breaking down the purchase price, the buyer's RCP Meadows LLC paid $45,125 per unit to MuniMaE's SCA Meadows LP.

The Shelby County Assessor of Property appraised the property for tax purposes at $6.1 million.
http://m.bizjournals.com/memphis/news/2014/01/16/meadows-memphis-rcp-general-munimae.html?r=full

Keep in mind that the REO was foreclosed during the financial crisis and aftermath - so it is likely carried at distressed prices.

Other items: the IHS AUM number was more recent than I gave it credit for - it is a 2013 number.  Also, with the restructuring we should see much lower SG&A going forward - at least unless the company starts expanding or generating new business - corporate headcount is down significantly.
Title: Re: MMAB - MuniMae, LLC
Post by: Myth465 on March 14, 2014, 05:04:38 PM
This looks like a very interesting idea.
I plan to listen to the next call and really spend sometime with the next 10K hopefully it doesnt run before than.

Thanks Olmsted. Perfect play for ROIC and GPT money.
Title: Re: MMAB - MuniMae, LLC
Post by: no_thanks on March 21, 2014, 06:55:34 AM
10-K is out. 

http://munimae.investorroom.com/index.php?s=127
Title: Re: MMAB - MuniMae, LLC
Post by: Olmsted on June 05, 2014, 01:48:29 PM
For those still watching, a belated update:

Equity/share at $2.02 (They sold the REO that previously contributed to the $2 estimate, now it is official)
Buyback authorized up to $1.92

They put some cash to work buying back bonds they used to own, layering some TRS to get good mid-teen returns.

Now we're just waiting to see what the next phase looks like.

Latest transcript:
http://munimae.investorroom.com/download/MMAB_051914.pdf
Title: Re: MMAB - MuniMae, LLC
Post by: kmukul on June 27, 2014, 06:44:12 AM
Hi Olmsted,
 Thanks for this thread and telling about this stock. this has run up nicely in last few months and almost doubled. However based on the current numbers its still super cheap especially on the earnings basis and it seems it can go up 2-3 times easily from here also if these earnings are sustainable. And the buyback is also nice. I wonder why people like packer aren't interested in this, Is there any catch to it that I am not getting? Is the management trustworthy? Thanks a lot in advance I am really thankful for this stock :)
Title: Re: MMAB - MuniMae, LLC
Post by: Olmsted on June 29, 2014, 07:39:30 AM
Yes I am glad it is working out as well.  I still see this as a balance sheet-driven story, as the company's future business model is still yet to be unveiled.  The earnings picture is cloudy now from all the one-time events.
Title: Re: MMAB - MuniMae, LLC
Post by: Olmsted on November 11, 2014, 10:16:45 AM
Q3 Earnings out

Highlights:

-Equity per share up to $11.06 (from $9.69 in Q2)
-$2.75M operating income - not including any one-time events (and with this company, there are always lots of those)
     -Cost base down nicely while we wait for cash to be put to work
-Repurchased 240K shares in Q3.  Buyback in place up to $11.01.
-Path forward has not changed: "The task ahead of us remains clear, we need to wisely reinvest the cash we have generated from asset sales in ways that allow us to take advantage of our net operating losses going forward.  We see both investment and business opportunities which we think will allow us to make prudent use of our cash and help us build and expand our existing business lines"

http://mmacapitalmanagement.investorroom.com/2014-11-10-MMA-Capital-Management-Announces-Third-Quarter-2014-Financial-Results-Business-Update-and-Investor-Conference-Call

Other updates

-Executed 5:1 reverse split
-Listed as MMAC on NASDAQ
-Did a clever transaction to sell its low-income housing tax credit business, creating ~$15.8M NAV from something held at $0 (although accounting rules defer this gain), while retaining an option to buy it back later:

http://mmacapitalmanagement.investorroom.com/2014-10-14-MMA-Capital-Announces-a-Series-of-Transactions-Related-to-its-Tax-Credit-Equity-Business
Title: Re: MMAB - MuniMae, LLC
Post by: Olmsted on December 18, 2014, 11:36:49 AM
Quote
MMA Capital Management...announced the formation of a new subsidiary, MMA Energy Capital, LLC ("MMA Energy Capital"), that will partner with renewable energy developers, contractors and system owners to provide project capital necessary to develop and build world class renewable energy systems.  MMA Energy Capital will be headed by Managing Director Bob Hopper, a former executive with MMA Renewable Ventures and SunEdison.

MMA Energy Capital will provide custom solutions around construction debt, development capital and permanent debt that enable its customers to effectively develop and build projects with the certainty that their capital needs will be met through an efficient and collaborative process.  Our primary investment focus will be in the distributed solar power market where there continues to be a lack of capital to meet the rapid growth of the industry.


http://mmacapitalmanagement.investorroom.com/2014-12-15-MMA-Capital-Forms-MMA-Energy-Capital

http://www.mmaenergycapital.com/

The managing director, Bob Hopper, has a pretty good pedigree in the space:

[/list]
Title: Re: MMAB - MuniMae, LLC
Post by: globalfinancepartners on March 20, 2015, 08:28:17 AM
MMAC keeps plugging along - Q4 / yearend results out:

http://mmacapitalmanagement.investorroom.com/2015-03-18-MMA-Capital-Management-Announces-Fourth-Quarter-and-Full-Year-2014-Financial-Results-Business-Update-and-Investor-Conference-Call

Management has been buying -
http://www.sec.gov/cgi-bin/own-disp?action=getissuer&CIK=0001003201

Company has been and will continue to repurchase -
"In the fourth quarter we bought back 118,700 shares, and our Board has expanded and extended our buyback plan by another 300,000 shares.  We will continue to repurchase shares at prices that we believe are competitive with other investment opportunities and, as such, the Board has approved purchases at prices up to $12.51, our GAAP fully diluted common equity per share at year-end."

Thanks for the idea Olmstead - this one has offered plenty of time to accumulate below book.
Title: Re: MMAB - MuniMae, LLC
Post by: kmukul on March 20, 2015, 07:55:37 PM
Thanks olmsted and everyone, it seems story is still continuing
Title: Re: MMAC - MuniMae, LLC
Post by: globalfinancepartners on May 26, 2015, 11:18:23 AM
Update from management -

http://www.sec.gov/Archives/edgar/data/1003201/000114420415033337/v411554_8-k.htm

Note: this one is MMAC now, but thread is under old MMAB ticker.
Title: Re: MMAC - MMA Capital Management
Post by: globalfinancepartners on May 11, 2016, 11:03:47 AM
Conference call this afternoon, book value now at $18.62, repurchases and management share purchases continue almost daily -

http://mmacapitalmanagement.investorroom.com/2016-05-10-MMA-Capital-Management-Announces-First-Quarter-2016-Financial-Results-and-Investor-Conference-Call

"Lastly, the Board has authorized us to amend our repurchase plan to increase the maximum price at which we may buy back stock to our newly reported GAAP diluted common equity per share of $18.62"


http://www.sec.gov/Archives/edgar/data/1003201/000114420416100442/mmac-20160331x10q.htm
Title: Re: MMAB - MuniMae, LLC
Post by: Radio Free Cash Flow on May 11, 2016, 11:42:18 AM
They keep on finding value in their own backyard. Foreclosing on a non-performing bond netted them a nice gain on the sale of the underlying property.

They bought back another 200,000 shares in April and the first week of May, which should bump up book value by another 7 cents or so. Amazing what they are doing over there. I am surprised the stock is not up more today.

Title: Re: MMAC - MMA Capital Management LLC
Post by: globalfinancepartners on August 08, 2017, 10:46:54 AM
Weird open this morning.  Results out tomorrow. 

CEO has stayed busy adding shares alongside the company's own repurchases
https://www.sec.gov/cgi-bin/own-disp?action=getissuer&CIK=0001003201
Title: Re: MMAC - MMA Capital Management llc
Post by: globalfinancepartners on August 09, 2017, 06:09:02 AM
Results out -

There were 5,852,582 shares of common shares outstanding at August 3, 2017.
Common shareholders' equity - at end of period $127,547,000

https://www.sec.gov/Archives/edgar/data/1003201/000114420417041333/mmac-20170630x10q.htm

------
conference call on Thursday, August 10, 2017 at 8:30 a.m. ET

edit - added press release.  New repurchase limit is $24.94/sh

https://mmacapitalmanagement.investorroom.com/2017-08-09-MMA-Capital-Management-Announces-Second-Quarter-2017-Financial-Results-and-Investor-Conference-Call

Title: Re: MMAC - MMAC Capital Management
Post by: globalfinancepartners on January 09, 2018, 06:15:47 AM
https://www.sec.gov/Archives/edgar/data/1003201/000114420418001400/tv482850_8k.htm
Title: Re: MMAB - MuniMae, LLC
Post by: rogermunibond on January 09, 2018, 11:15:50 AM
Very nice.  This was a hugely deep value idea back in 2010-2011 when they were delisted and on the pink sheets.
Title: Re: MMAB - MuniMae, LLC
Post by: globalfinancepartners on May 10, 2018, 06:07:02 AM
Results are out at MMAC, still an interesting operation run by some really good people...

https://mmacapitalmanagement.investorroom.com/2018-05-10-MMA-Capital-Management-Announces-First-Quarter-Results-and-Investor-Conference-Call

https://www.sec.gov/Archives/edgar/data/1003201/000114420418026794/mmac-20180331x10q.htm

"Diluted common shareholders’ equity (“Book Value”) per share increased $6.34 per share in the first quarter of 2018 to $30.82 at March 31, 2018. "
Title: Re: MMAC - MMA Capital Management
Post by: globalfinancepartners on August 10, 2018, 06:32:35 AM
Results out, book value up to $32.02 / share

https://mmacapitalmanagement.investorroom.com/2018-08-09-MMA-Capital-Management-Announces-Second-Quarter-Results-and-Investor-Conference-Call

Title: Re: MMAB - MuniMae, LLC
Post by: Libs on November 08, 2018, 11:48:21 AM
This sure has been a home run. Well done, guys. I love these BV growth plays.

But....this is a debt-oriented company, in areas that seem shaky, no? Affordable housing ( with 1.1X debt service coverage per the 10-K) and renewable energy ( which seems beholden to tax incentives).

I notice that Falcone has been prominent since 1997, and CEO since 2005. So, he was instrumental in the blow-up a decade ago. How does that figure into people's thinking here? Just how risky is this?

Title: Re: MMAB - MuniMae, LLC
Post by: globalfinancepartners on November 08, 2018, 12:12:17 PM
It has been a delightful investment.  About to report book value above $34 per share and available very recently in the $25's.  I don't think it is correct that Michael Falcone was involved with the company during the MuniMae blow up.  He was CEO of MMA Capital management since 2005, but MMA Capital management was not the same as MuniMae, the mess of a shell he took over.
** This is incorrect.  falcone was in fact involved with MuniMae - my apologies **
https://www.businesswire.com/news/home/20041209005690/en/MuniMae-Announces-CEO-Succession-Michael-L.-Falcone

As for how risky it is?  Who knows!  The people with the greatest grasp on the business continue to put more of their net worth into the shares and repurchase shares below book.  I'm holding for a while longer

By the way, Libs, are you "libertarians_2000" from back in the day?

This sure has been a home run. Well done, guys. I love these BV growth plays.

But....this is a debt-oriented company, in areas that seem shaky, no? Affordable housing ( with 1.1X debt service coverage per the 10-K) and renewable energy ( which seems beholden to tax incentives).

I notice that Falcone has been prominent since 1997, and CEO since 2005. So, he was instrumental in the blow-up a decade ago. How does that figure into people's thinking here? Just how risky is this?
Title: Re: MMAB - MuniMae, LLC
Post by: misterkrusty on November 08, 2018, 03:16:38 PM
Sometimes people get religion.  I wrote this up on the VIC in the $2s (then sold in the $4s partly due to not being sure about Falcone).

Renta Corporacion in Spain is another case of a company run by a guy who blew up in the housing bubble (in this case, the one in Spain) who is now doing all the right things.  Full disclosure: I'm long Renta.
Title: Re: MMAB - MuniMae, LLC
Post by: Libs on November 09, 2018, 09:54:44 AM
<By the way, Libs, are you "libertarians_2000" from back in the day?>

Yessir. I've always appreciated your insights and wit, GFP, and am glad to have found you here.

Re MMAC, I found this really compelling a few years ago; I bought and quickly doubled up when the price / BV gap closed. Then I stupidly sold, thinking it was played out, at around $15.

It's still tempting, but I just don't quite get how they keep pulling these rabbits out of their hat to increase BV over and over again. And I don't know enough about their business to understand just how risky that debt service number
( 1.1X) is.





Title: Re: MMAB - MuniMae, LLC
Post by: globalfinancepartners on November 09, 2018, 10:02:05 AM
Well one rabbit that works pretty reliably is repurchasing your own shares way below book value per share, further increasing BVPS without actually having to create any wealth the "hard way."  But it takes an accurate understanding that your BVPS is actually money good!  (and your stock has to stay available at those prices long enough to keep doing it)

<By the way, Libs, are you "libertarians_2000" from back in the day?>

Yessir. I've always appreciated your insights and wit, GFP, and am glad to have found you here.

Re MMAC, I found this really compelling a few years ago; I bought and quickly doubled up when the price / BV gap closed. Then I stupidly sold, thinking it was played out, at around $15.

It's still tempting, but I just don't quite get how they keep pulling these rabbits out of their hat to increase BV over and over again. And I don't know enough about their business to understand just how risky that debt service number
( 1.1X) is.
Title: Re: MMAB - MuniMae, LLC
Post by: globalfinancepartners on November 10, 2018, 07:54:04 AM
Well I was high in my estimate of book value per share when I said 'over 34' - they reported $32.96 per diluted share.

I had neglected to notice the Hunt transaction would be recognized int he 4th quarter, looking like at least $35.31(+) BVPS for the 4th Quarter

https://www.sec.gov/Archives/edgar/data/1003201/000114420418058816/tv504548_10q.htm

https://mmacapitalmanagement.investorroom.com/2018-11-09-MMA-Capital-Management-Announces-Third-Quarter-Results-and-Investor-Conference-Call

Quote
"In addition, the Board approved an extension of the 2018 buyback program earlier this week by 31,250 shares, which increased the total amount of authorized shares to be repurchased to 218,750 shares, as well as increased the maximum price to be paid to $32.96 per share.  The Company has purchased 187,500 shares year-to-date at an average price of $27.25 per share. Historically, share buybacks have been accretive and, therefore, have helped drive growth in Book Value per share.  On a cumulative basis over the past six years, we have bought back over 3.2 million shares at an average price of approximately $13.51.  We may continue using buybacks to be opportunistic in periods of significant disconnect between our Book Value per share and trading price, similar to today's environment, but the long-term sustainability of the Company will continue to be driven by our future investments in real estate and infrastructure, particularly in renewable energy, as we focus on growing the business in the coming years."