Author Topic: VTU.L - Vertu Motors  (Read 10051 times)

whistlerbumps

  • Full Member
  • ***
  • Posts: 162
VTU.L - Vertu Motors
« on: March 09, 2015, 12:19:12 PM »
VTU is a UK car dealership that is undervalued because current margins have been depressed by the company's strategy of acquiring and turning around loss-making dealerships.  There is no structural reason why VTU's margins should not approach the 2.0%+ achieved by peers LOOK and PDG's volume division.  At 2%, EPS would be ~GBp 10 which could generate a 100% return with a 12x P/E.  Even with current depressed margins, VTU earning ~5p so downside seems protected near current share price.  Strong balance sheet and good management team in my opinion. 

« Last Edit: March 09, 2015, 12:34:21 PM by Parsad »



whistlerbumps

  • Full Member
  • ***
  • Posts: 162
Re: VTU.L - Vertu Motors
« Reply #2 on: April 07, 2017, 09:32:41 AM »
Thanks. I still think Vertu is massively mispriced at current levels unless the UK enters into a severe recession. 

muscleman

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Posts: 3191
Re: VTU.L - Vertu Motors
« Reply #3 on: April 09, 2017, 09:58:42 AM »
https://gallery.mailchimp.com/6baeceda9bb7d6e6ebecd0933/files/3bb56367-8cdf-4c1b-82d5-2df038189c83/C4KMMI1_IBV_Capital_on_Vertu_Motors.pdf?utm_source=Capitalize+for+Kids+Investors+Conference+2016&utm_campaign=560d832f8c-EMAIL_CAMPAIGN_2017_03_14&utm_medium=email&utm_term=0_058eb76957-560d832f8c-517270177

"This is in part due to legislation, which forbids manufacturers from owning their own dealerships (in most states), as well as strong dealership contracts that make agreement terminations by manufacturers very difficult. "

They said this for the US dealerships. Do you know if the UK dealerships have this kind of advantage?
I am muslceman. I have more muscle than brain!

whistlerbumps

  • Full Member
  • ***
  • Posts: 162
Re: VTU.L - Vertu Motors
« Reply #4 on: April 25, 2017, 07:50:15 AM »
UK dealer/manufacturer relations are governed by Europe block exemption rules. They are not quite as dealer friendly as the US system but its still very rare to see a dealer terminated.  More often, the manufacturer will work to push the sale of an underperforming dealership.

kab60

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Posts: 1005
Re: VTU.L - Vertu Motors
« Reply #5 on: September 10, 2019, 10:45:01 AM »
Took a position today. Trades at 50 pct of BV or 35c vs 45c tangible book. Net cash of 20m, 3,2xev/ebitda FYE. New car sales is already in a recession in the UK, but the jewel is service which grew 8 pct. in most recent period.

Not gonna happen, but if they took leverage to x1ebitda they could almost retire half the shares for a proforma PE of 4.

They have spent 85m on capex in the last 3 years (and returns are not impressive but possibly deflated from buying struggling dealerships) vs a market cap of 125m currently.

After massive upgrades capex is projected to come down, so they'll harvest free cash. Their historic returns are mixed if not bad, but they seem to have smartened up and buyback shares (some 7-10 pct returned through divy and buybacks anually).

Cambria, another UK dealership, is a better business, but they're looking at massive upgrades and it is more expensive - though very cheap. Might take a stake there as well (also bought Motorpoint, a sort of UK Carmax).



maude

  • Newbie
  • *
  • Posts: 3
Re: VTU.L - Vertu Motors
« Reply #6 on: September 10, 2019, 11:23:41 AM »
I used to own Vertu as well, but I think Cambria will create more per-share value over time. Plus, Cambria has a significant near-to-medium term tailwind from the new luxury dealerships, which have yet to contribute much to profits. My biggest complaint about Vertu is they issued equity a few times when the stock was trading at low multiples. Cambria will almost certainly never do that. I wonder if Robert Forrester has truly changed his philosophy about this. My guess is not, and they have told me in recent months they would issue equity if at some point they have an opportunity to make a very large, transformative acquisition (buying another large dealership group). They didn't have any expectation this would happen any time soon.

kab60

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Posts: 1005
Re: VTU.L - Vertu Motors
« Reply #7 on: September 10, 2019, 11:51:48 AM »
I used to own Vertu as well, but I think Cambria will create more per-share value over time. Plus, Cambria has a significant near-to-medium term tailwind from the new luxury dealerships, which have yet to contribute much to profits. My biggest complaint about Vertu is they issued equity a few times when the stock was trading at low multiples. Cambria will almost certainly never do that. I wonder if Robert Forrester has truly changed his philosophy about this. My guess is not, and they have told me in recent months they would issue equity if at some point they have an opportunity to make a very large, transformative acquisition (buying another large dealership group). They didn't have any expectation this would happen any time soon.
Thanks, much appreciated. Sounds terrible and fits a nagging feeling I have (their new chairman is a car guy- Cambrias has a corporate finance background and knows about ROIC above WACC...) Did you get a feel for what drives Vertus ambition and whether they weigh all capital allocation decisions through the same lens (by buying shares they "buy" dealerships and half of what they paid) or they just wanna grow for growths sake? What do they mean by transformational? Forrester owns 2%, but he might be driven by ego?

cmlber

  • Sr. Member
  • ****
  • Posts: 470
Re: VTU.L - Vertu Motors
« Reply #8 on: September 10, 2019, 04:55:37 PM »
I used to own Vertu as well, but I think Cambria will create more per-share value over time. Plus, Cambria has a significant near-to-medium term tailwind from the new luxury dealerships, which have yet to contribute much to profits. My biggest complaint about Vertu is they issued equity a few times when the stock was trading at low multiples. Cambria will almost certainly never do that. I wonder if Robert Forrester has truly changed his philosophy about this. My guess is not, and they have told me in recent months they would issue equity if at some point they have an opportunity to make a very large, transformative acquisition (buying another large dealership group). They didn't have any expectation this would happen any time soon.
Thanks, much appreciated. Sounds terrible and fits a nagging feeling I have (their new chairman is a car guy- Cambrias has a corporate finance background and knows about ROIC above WACC...) Did you get a feel for what drives Vertus ambition and whether they weigh all capital allocation decisions through the same lens (by buying shares they "buy" dealerships and half of what they paid) or they just wanna grow for growths sake? What do they mean by transformational? Forrester owns 2%, but he might be driven by ego?

Lavery (CAMB) and Forrester (VTU) both started these businesses in 2006.  Lavery turned an initial base of 10.8MM in capital into 57MM in market value today but over the same period with the same opportunity set Forrester turned 0.60/share into 0.33/share.  Imo, that's all you need to know...

Arguably Vertu is under earning today, but even if you give them credit for doubling margins to peer levels and assume a constant multiple, he still created no value for shareholders over 13 years.  The only way those returns are possible when they've been retaining earnings is if they have been issuing equity at lower valuations than their acquisitions...

I asked Forrester if there's anything he would change about their strategy or execution in hindsight, expecting to hear that he wouldn't have issued cheap equity, and he said no there's nothing he would change.  He also mentioned their M&A target is a yr3 multiple of 5x EBITDA and I asked why he would do that when they can buy their own business with no execution risk at 3x EBITDA and he basically said if you don't have scale then when there is a mass consolidation in dealers in the near future VTU could be screwed by OEMs.  There is some logic to that assuming M&A is only marginally more expensive than buying your own stock, but given the disparity in values we were talking about, it makes no sense. 

maude

  • Newbie
  • *
  • Posts: 3
Re: VTU.L - Vertu Motors
« Reply #9 on: September 10, 2019, 06:15:24 PM »
By "transformational" deal, they just meant "very large" deal. My impression from a couple of conversations with Robert Forrester (Vertu CEO) is that he wants to turn Vertu into a big dealership group (basically empire building).
I think Robert Forrester started talking about the logic in stock buybacks, he read The Outsiders, etc. I think this happened shortly after the last equity offering, which was not well-received by investors. My feeling is he may be trying to placate investors.
In my many conversations with Mark Lavery (Cambria CEO), he has always seemed to be very focused on per-share value (and his long-term track record supports this).